Subscribe to
Posts
Comments

Are tags over-rated?

Jeff Atwood [twitter:codinghorror] , a founder of Stackoverflow and Discourse.org — two of my favorite sites — is on a tear about tags. Here are his two tweets that started the discussion:

I am deeply ambivalent about tags as a panacea based on my experience with them at Stack Overflow/Exchange. Example: pic.twitter.com/AA3Y1NNCV9

Here’s a detweetified version of the four-part tweet I posted in reply:

Jeff’s right that tags are not a panacea, but who said they were? They’re a tool (frequently most useful when combined with an old-fashioned taxonomy), and if a tool’s not doing the job, then drop it. Or, better, fix it. Because tags are an abstract idea that exists only in particular implementations.

After all, one could with some plausibility claim that online discussions are the most overrated concept in the social media world. But still they have value. That indicates an opportunity to build a better discussion service. … which is exactly what Jeff did by building Discourse.org.

Finally, I do think it’s important — even while trying to put tags into a less over-heated perspective [do perspectives overheat??] — to remember that when first introduced in the early 2000s, tags represented an important break with an old and long tradition that used the authority to classify as a form of power. Even if tagging isn’t always useful and isn’t as widely applicable as some of us thought it would be, tagging has done the important work of telling us that we as individuals and as a loose collective now have a share of that power in our hands. That’s no small thing.

6 Responses to “Are tags over-rated?”

  1. on 09 Apr 2014 at 3:31 amSBOBET

    Thanks!

  2. on 06 Aug 2014 at 4:31 pmo come all ye faithful chords

    of course like your web-site however you have to take
    a look at the spelling on quite a few of your
    posts. A number of them are rife with spelling problems and
    I to find it very troublesome to tell the reality on the other hand I will certainly come back
    again.

    Check out my page; o come all ye faithful chords

  3. on 10 Oct 2014 at 9:54 pmzerquetscht

    Appreciat? thi? post. Will try it o?t.

    Feel free t? visit my blog post … zerquetscht

  4. on 11 Oct 2014 at 2:22 pmcoolukpayday

    Generally , loan finders looking for payday advances are allowed 14 to 31 days as refund length which is really extremely short

  5. on 15 Oct 2014 at 12:51 amcosto ugg bassi

    costo ugg bassi pantofole ugg uomo YzDQR Wall Street: Geld gleitet nie (öffnet heute):
    Diese Oliver Stone Film ist eine Fortsetzung der 1987 Film Wall Street.
    guanti ugg milano Vendita Ugg RAFoi Deshalb ist eine Flotte von Magnet Powered Taxis, nach dem Vorbild der eleganten Wendung der
    Tom Cruise in dem Bericht Minoriti rollte über den Boden des Schneideraums.
    ugg usa uggs shoes AEJpv Palmer, ein Tribut Weg wurde in seiner Ehre bei
    Red Run-Stream Valley Trail in November 2013 mit dem Namen [5]Michael Phelps ist Svimmer
    der meist dekorierten Olympia aller Zeiten mit einer Karriere insgesamt 22 Medaillen, darunter 18 Gold, aber die
    Zahlen sagen nicht, ein Teil der Geschichte. ebay ugg stivali uggs
    on sale lcZbf Am Deus Da Nya, muito verehrt junto do Lago Straße Pushkar, Senda
    Q. sandali stivali ugg negozi milano tDihD Schließlich könnte es
    davon zu überzeugen, Alfred Fuchs und Lucio zurück, um seine Hilfe nach
    der Enthüllung des Superman hat sich weltweit
    eine riesige Spiel-Wechsler.

  6. on 10 Dec 2014 at 8:54 pmVanita

    Quality articles is the secret to invite the users to pay a visit the
    web site, that’s what this web site is providing.

Leave a Reply